Best Ice Cream Shops in Sutton

Afters Sutton is a popular ice cream parlor known for its creative and often nostalgic flavor combinations, appealing to a wide range of tastes. The menu is extensive, featuring signature creations like the Cookie Monster and Birthday Cake, alongside a variety of other ice creams, sundaes, waffles, and crepes. They offer cold stone ice cream and customizable options. Afters Sutton is available for delivery through Uber Eats within the London area. While generally well-received, some reviews mention occasional issues with service, cleanliness, and the availability of certain items. There is a noticeable lack of vegan options. The website highlights the diverse menu and delivery options, emphasizing the ability to create custom ice cream experiences.

Fentons Creamery is a historic ice cream parlor, established in 1894 and renowned for its handmade ice cream and quality ingredients. It’s a landmark with a rich legacy, credited with inventing iconic flavors like Rocky Road and Swiss Milk Chocolate. The Creamery faced a devastating fire in 2001 but was lovingly rebuilt with community support, and gained further recognition as the birthplace of Rocky Road ice cream. Its appearance in the Pixar film *Up* solidified its place in popular culture. Fentons offers a classic selection of grilled sandwiches, burgers, and salads alongside its extensive ice cream menu, featuring both traditional and nostalgic flavors. The shop also sells merchandise and is known for its ‘Banana Special’ sundae. It currently operates three locations in California, including one in the Oakland International Airport.