Best Ice Cream Shops in Plymouth

Pilgrims Ice Cream was a takeaway food shop specializing in ice cream, established in 2016 and dissolved in 2022. Reviews describe it as a popular spot near the Barbican in Plymouth, offering a wide variety of flavors, including nostalgic options like Rum & Raisin and Unicorn, as well as dog-friendly choices. Service can be busy during peak times, particularly on weekends, but the quality of the ice cream is consistently praised. Some reviewers mention long queues and occasional rudeness from staff, while others highlight the kindness and generosity of the owners, such as replacing a child’s dropped ice cream without charge. The shop offers a diverse selection of flavors, from classic to unique, and caters to various preferences. The website provides limited information about the business.

Berties Ice Cream and Homemade Desserts is a Plymouth-based business specializing in handcrafted ice cream and desserts, primarily catering to commercial clients. They offer a diverse range of flavors, including traditional and plant-based options, with a strong focus on dietary needs like gluten-free and vegan choices. Reviews consistently praise the quality of the ice cream, the friendly service, and the unique flavor combinations, such as blackcurrant and liquorice. Some customers have noted a potential issue with hair in the ice cream, highlighting a need for improved hygiene practices. The business is known for its bulk catering options and commitment to providing high-quality ingredients. Overall, Berties is viewed as a popular and reliable supplier of ice cream for various establishments.

Sundaes Gelato Plymouth is a popular dessert destination in Plymouth, known for its high-quality ice cream, waffles, and sundaes. Established in 2016, the business prides itself on using premium ingredients and creating a delightful experience for its customers. Reviews consistently highlight the deliciousness of their offerings, particularly the banana splits, and the friendly service. While some customers have noted that the prices are a bit steep and that the location is inconvenient, the overall sentiment is positive. The business is actively involved in the local community and offers a student discount. Despite some customer feedback about the need for a location outside of Plymouth, Sundaes Gelato remains a beloved spot for dessert lovers in the city.

Surfing Cow Gelato is a family-run ice cream business located on South Battisborough Farm in Holbeton, Plymouth. They are known for producing and selling their gelato in biodegradable tubs, emphasizing a commitment to sustainable practices. Reviews highlight both the deliciousness of the gelato and the beautiful farm setting. Some customers appreciate the unique experience of visiting a working farm and enjoying ice cream amidst the cows and coastal views. However, some reviews mention long queues and a slightly higher price point. The coffee is often noted as being less successful than the ice cream. Overall, Surfing Cow Gelato offers a delightful treat in a charming environment, though potential visitors should be aware of possible wait times and the cost.

Ocean City: Coffee and Ice Cream is a specialty coffee and tea retailer with multiple locations, offering a variety of coffee drinks, teas, and pastries. The company prides itself on sourcing high-quality, small-batch roasted coffees from around the world and roasting them in-house. Customer feedback is mixed, with many appreciating the quality of the coffee, particularly the matcha and specialty drinks, and the friendly atmosphere. However, some customers have reported slow service, bland coffee, and high prices. The business emphasizes in-house roasting, freshness, multiple locations, and seasonal specials. It offers a rewards program and limited-time offers, and highlights the expertise of its baristas. They also accept credit cards with a $5 minimum fee.