Best Ice Cream Shops in Mexborough

The Proper Ice Cream Company is a popular ice cream shop in Doncaster, known for its high-quality, handcrafted ice cream and baked goods. Reviews consistently praise the delicious flavors, creamy texture, and friendly service. Customers rave about the variety of options, particularly mentioning favorites like Terry Chocolate Orange, Mint Aero, and Kinderella. The shop is described as a ‘gem’ and a ‘must-try’ experience, with many visitors traveling from afar to sample its offerings. Several reviewers highlight the care and attention to detail that goes into each product, noting the freshness and quality of the ingredients. The business also offers a selection of cakes and cheesecakes, which are frequently praised for their taste and presentation. While the website is currently unavailable, social media presence confirms a strong community following and consistent updates on new flavors and promotions. Some customers have expressed a desire for healthier options, but so far, no confirmed healthy options have been identified.