Best Ice Cream Shops in Innerleithen

Caldwell Homemade Ice Cream Ltd is a long-standing ice cream shop with a history dating back to 2013, currently run by Angela Archibald and Janice Todd. While the Peebles location is closing in autumn 2024 due to the directors wanting to prioritize family life, the Innerleithen shop remains open and continues to operate at local events. Reviews consistently praise the quality of the homemade ice cream, with many highlighting the wide selection of flavors and the friendly service. Some reviewers mention that the shop is a popular stop for cyclists and visitors to the Tweed Valley. A few reviews note that the pricing is somewhat high, and one mentions a past issue with slow service and a lack of ice cream selection. Despite some occasional drawbacks, the overall sentiment is positive, with customers appreciating the delicious ice cream and the shop's role in the community. The business is listed as gluten-free on the Atly website.