Best Ice Cream Shops in Coleraine

Braemar Farm Ice Cream is an artisan ice cream producer based in Castlerock, Northern Ireland. They specialize in creating delicious, real dairy ice cream using milk from their family’s dairy herd and incorporating high-quality local ingredients. They operate a trailer on the promenade and are increasingly supplying local shops, restaurants, and cafes. Reviews consistently praise the quality and taste of their ice cream, highlighting favorites like the Hokey Pokey Honeycomb and the unique ‘Cow Pat’ flavor. While some customers appreciate the traditional methods and local ingredients, others noted a slight discrepancy between the expected chocolate brownie flavor and the vanilla ice cream with brownie bits in one particular order. Overall, Braemar Farm Ice Cream is well-regarded for its delicious ice cream and convenient location.

Mullins Ice Cream Shop has a rich history dating back to 1932 in Ireland, founded by Frank Mullen Sr. and his sons as a dairy farm and bottling operation. They transitioned to ice cream production in the 1940s, establishing a reputation for creamy, homemade ice cream using local ingredients. The shop prides itself on small-batch production and a community focus, aiming to bring families and friends together. Mullins utilizes a four-step process – pasteurization, homogenization, inclusions, and blast freezing – to create its award-winning ice cream. Currently, Mullins operates in Watertown and Oconomowoc, Wisconsin, offering a range of flavors and a commitment to quality. Reviews indicate a fondness for the shop's creamy texture and delicious flavors, though some customers have expressed concerns about portion sizes and pricing. Despite some criticisms, Mullins remains a popular local favorite.